FAN logo
Falsely Accused Network
Set up by the falsely accused, for the falsely accused.
Menu

← Back to Blog & Insights

When Allegations Become Accepted as Fact: A Family Court Judgment Raises Serious Questions

Family Court papers and gavel in a courtroom, illustrating fact-finding hearings in child arrangements cases

A November 2026 Family Court judgment highlights the dangers of untested allegations, incomplete evidence and the consequences for parents and children when accusations begin to shape professional decision-making.

By Falsely Accused Network | Family Court Analysis | November 2026

A recent Family Court judgment has raised important questions about how allegations of domestic abuse are assessed, how information is shared between professionals, and what happens when disputed accounts begin to influence decisions affecting a child's relationship with a parent.

In EM v PF (Fact Finding) [2026] EWFC 327 (B), Recorder Lucy Reed KC examined allegations made by a mother against her former partner, including sexual assault, coercive and controlling behaviour, harassment and concerns about his parenting.

Following a three-day fact-finding hearing in October 2026, the court rejected several serious allegations against the father, while making more limited findings concerning his exposure of their child to inappropriate material.

The judgment also revealed concerns about the accuracy of information passed to professionals, incomplete WhatsApp evidence and the extent to which an interim non-molestation order had influenced perceptions of the father.

It is important to be clear from the outset: the court did not find that any allegation was deliberately false. Allegations that were not proved were simply not established on the evidence.

For anyone concerned about fairness in family proceedings, this case deserves careful examination.

A father whose relationship with his child became restricted

The parents shared care of their six-year-old son, who was experiencing significant emotional and behavioural difficulties and was undergoing assessment for possible neurodevelopmental conditions.

The mother had obtained an interim non-molestation order in November 2025.

In May 2026, she stopped the father's contact with their son following an alleged breach of that order.

The father subsequently made an urgent application to the Family Court seeking child arrangements.

An interim arrangement was introduced allowing him four hours of supervised contact each week.

Importantly, the judgment records that the supervised contact sessions were consistently positive. Supervisors raised no safeguarding concerns about the father's interactions with his son.

The child was also regularly distressed when the sessions ended because he did not want to leave his father.

Nevertheless, the father remained subject to restricted contact while the proceedings continued.

This illustrates a difficult reality of family proceedings: protective arrangements can have significant consequences for family relationships before disputed allegations have been determined.

Such arrangements may be necessary where genuine risks exist. However, their existence must not be mistaken for proof that the allegations underlying them are true.

The missing WhatsApp messages

One of the most significant aspects of the judgment concerned evidence that had not initially been included in the court bundle.

The judge considered approximately 900 pages of documents, including witness statements, school records, police disclosure, social care information and communications between the parents.

However, a further 57 pages of WhatsApp messages were admitted after the close of evidence.

These messages covered the summer of 2025, an important period preceding the mother's first police report and her application for a non-molestation order.

The judge considered the messages highly relevant.

The original transcript had been selectively prepared, but neither the exhibited transcript nor the accompanying statement made clear that relevant exchanges had been omitted.

The Recorder emphasised that proportionality in preparing evidence must not come at the expense of full and frank disclosure.

The judge did not blame either parent for the omission and did not determine that the editing had been deliberately misleading.

Nevertheless, the episode raises a wider concern.

If communications are presented without their full context, could a court or professional be left with an inaccurate impression of the relationship between two parents?

In this case, the missing messages demonstrated periods of cooperation, friendly communication and positive interaction between the parents.

That context mattered when assessing allegations concerning the father's behaviour and the nature of their post-separation relationship.

When professional reports repeat disputed allegations

Perhaps the most troubling wider issue raised by the judgment is the way information moved between the mother, the school, social services and other professionals.

Throughout the proceedings, concerns about the father's conduct were repeatedly communicated to agencies involved with the child.

Some concerns were supported by direct professional observations. Others originated from the mother's accounts.

The distinction was important.

For example, the mother reported that the father had behaved in an intimidating manner during interactions at school.

However, the judge identified occasions where the descriptions given to police were not corroborated by contemporaneous school records.

In another instance, the mother reported that the father had failed to respond to concerns about their child.

The parenting-app records showed that he had responded before the referral was logged.

The judge also examined concerns about alleged tracking, possible child abduction and other safeguarding matters, identifying an absence of supporting evidence in the available police disclosure.

These discrepancies did not mean every concern was unfounded. Indeed, the court accepted that some concerns about inappropriate media exposure were legitimate.

But they demonstrated why the source, accuracy and context of information must be carefully examined.

A concern reported by one parent is not automatically an independently established fact simply because it subsequently appears in a professional record.

That distinction is fundamental to procedural fairness.

An interim court order is not proof of abuse

One of the judgment's most significant observations concerned the non-molestation order.

The mother had obtained the order without notice to the father, and its existence subsequently formed part of the background considered by professionals.

However, an interim protective order is not itself a finding that the allegations have been proved.

The Recorder expressed concern that professionals had treated the existence of the order as evidence of ongoing abuse.

At paragraph 143, the judge explained that the order had influenced professional perceptions and had distorted the balance between the parents in a way that was unhelpful to their child.

This is a particularly important distinction.

Non-molestation orders serve a vital protective function, and courts must be able to intervene where there is a genuine need for protection.

But where an order has been made on an interim basis, particularly without the other party being heard, it should not automatically be treated as conclusive evidence of wrongdoing.

Otherwise, there is a risk that an allegation can acquire increasing apparent credibility simply through being repeated in subsequent records and decisions.

The existence of an order may be relevant. Its evidential significance must still be understood correctly.

Serious allegations that were not proved

The court considered several allegations against the father.

One concerned alleged sexual harassment and assault in August 2025.

The judge carefully considered the competing accounts, the surrounding communications and the reliability of the evidence.

The allegation was not proved.

The judge also rejected allegations that the father had intentionally withheld information to distress the mother or deliberately obstructed effective co-parenting.

The allegations of post-separation coercive control and harassment were likewise rejected.

The court found that disagreement over parenting arrangements did not, in itself, establish harassment or controlling behaviour.

That is an important principle.

Separated parents may disagree strongly about arrangements for their children. Communication may become strained, inflexible or unpleasant.

Such behaviour should be assessed in its proper context, rather than automatically classified as domestic abuse.

Equally, genuine coercive control can involve subtle patterns of behaviour that may not be obvious when incidents are considered individually.

The challenge for courts is to distinguish between these situations by examining the evidence.

The court did make findings against the father concerning his exposure of the child to inappropriate media content on more than one occasion.

However, it rejected the suggestion that the father's care alone explained the child's behavioural difficulties.

The judge recognised that the child's likely neurodivergence, transitions between homes, parental conflict and other changes in his life could all have contributed.

The judgment was therefore not an unconditional endorsement of either parent's conduct. It was a detailed assessment of what the evidence did, and did not, establish.

The consequences for the child

At the centre of these proceedings was a six-year-old boy who loved both his parents.

The court recognised the importance of his relationship with each of them.

The father had experienced months of restricted contact, despite positive observations from the contact centre and Cafcass.

Following the fact-finding hearing, the judge considered that there was little remaining justification for continuing supervised contact.

The judge also indicated that the non-molestation order should not be extended.

The published judgment records that the parents subsequently agreed arrangements under which contact would continue weekly for the same duration, with handovers facilitated by the centre but without supervision.

The non-molestation proceedings were concluded without further order.

The wider child arrangements proceedings were not finally resolved by this judgment.

Nevertheless, the case demonstrates why fact-finding matters.

Where allegations are disputed, careful judicial scrutiny can materially change the assessment of risk and the arrangements considered appropriate for a child.

What this judgment tells us about fairness

At Falsely Accused Network, we recognise that domestic abuse is a serious issue and that genuine victims must be protected.

We also recognise that allegations can be disputed, exaggerated, mistaken or, in some circumstances, deliberately false.

Those possibilities must not be treated as interchangeable.

An allegation that is not proved has not necessarily been shown to be deliberately fabricated.

Equally, the seriousness of an allegation does not remove the need to examine the evidence supporting it.

This judgment highlights several important lessons.

First, allegations must be distinguished from established findings. Professional records should make clear whether information is directly observed, independently corroborated or simply reported by one party.

Second, evidence must be considered in context. Selectively presented communications can create an incomplete picture, even where omissions were not intended to mislead.

Third, interim protective measures should not be confused with proof of wrongdoing. Their purpose is protection, not the final determination of disputed facts.

Fourth, children's needs must remain central. Where contact is restricted, the reasons should remain subject to appropriate scrutiny and review.

Finally, fairness protects everyone. A system that carefully tests evidence is better equipped both to protect genuine victims and to avoid unjustified findings against those accused.

Our conclusion

The significance of EM v PF is not simply that several serious allegations against a father were rejected.

It is that the judgment demonstrates how complex family disputes can become when allegations, professional concerns, interim court orders and conflicting parental accounts interact.

The judge's examination of the evidence revealed a more nuanced picture than some earlier records had suggested.

It also demonstrated the importance of preserving complete communications, questioning unsupported assumptions and distinguishing genuine safeguarding concerns from allegations that have not been established.

For the Falsely Accused Network, the central message is straightforward:

An allegation must be taken seriously. But taking an allegation seriously is not the same as treating it as proven.

That principle is essential to protecting genuine victims, ensuring fairness to accused individuals and, above all, safeguarding the welfare of children.

Case reference

EM v PF (Fact Finding) [2026] EWFC 327 (B)

Family Court sitting in Bournemouth

Recorder Lucy Reed KC

Judgment handed down: 9 November 2026

This article is commentary on a published, anonymised Family Court judgment. It does not suggest that any allegation was knowingly fabricated unless the court expressly made such a finding. It is not legal advice.


About Falsely Accused Network

Falsely Accused Network provides professional, paid McKenzie Friend support to people involved in family court proceedings in England and Wales, including those facing disputed or allegedly false allegations of domestic abuse.

We assist with child arrangements, non-molestation orders, occupation orders, court preparation and hearings.

Our services are individually quoted, and an initial call is available to discuss the assistance you may require.

Website: www.falselyaccusednetwork.co.uk

Email: support@falselyaccusednetwork.co.uk

Set up by the falsely accused, for the falsely accused.

Request Your Free Initial Call