A High Court judgment has exposed serious failings in family court proceedings involving disputed domestic abuse allegations, concerns about children’s relationships with their parents, and years of delay.
In Re A and T (Children) [2025] EWHC 3052 (Fam), Mr Justice Harrison considered an appeal brought by a father who had spent years attempting to rebuild his relationship with his two children.
The case raises important questions about procedural fairness, the handling of disputed allegations, professional accountability and the impact of prolonged litigation on children.
The judge delivered a particularly troubling assessment:
“Most regrettably, this is a family which has been let down by the system.”
Years of Proceedings Without Resolution
The parents separated in 2016. Alternate-weekend contact continued for a time but ended in 2017, after the mother moved without giving the father her new address.
In December 2020, after obtaining the mother’s contact details, the father applied for a Child Arrangements Order.
The mother made allegations of serious domestic abuse, which the father consistently denied. The father alleged that the children had been alienated from him.
A fact-finding hearing before lay justices eventually took place in April 2022, approximately 16 months after the father’s application. The justices considered four of twelve alleged incidents and made findings against the father on three.
In August 2022, a circuit judge set those findings aside because the process by which they had been made was unfair.
A further fact-finding hearing was later ordered, before the court decided that the factual disputes could be dealt with at the final hearing instead. In the event, no fact-finding took place because the parents reached agreement. The disputed allegations were never determined.
This absence of clear findings created significant difficulties for the professionals involved and complicated efforts to establish appropriate arrangements for the children.
Professionals Criticised for Accepting Unproven Allegations
One of the most significant aspects of the judgment concerns the approach taken by professionals to allegations that had not been judicially determined.
The children’s guardian considered that professionals had contributed to the harm by accepting at face value the mother’s assertions about the risks posed by the father.
A court order made in December 2023 had expressly reminded professionals to keep an open mind and not to assume that either parent was telling the truth.
The High Court also highlighted the difficulties created by repeated changes of guardian and social worker.
This raises a fundamental issue of fairness. Domestic abuse allegations must be taken seriously, but allegations and established facts are not the same thing. Safeguarding concerns should be investigated appropriately, and professionals must remain objective while factual disputes are unresolved.
Importantly, the High Court did not find that the mother’s allegations were false. Nor did it make any finding on the father’s alienation allegations. Both remained disputed and unresolved.
Concerns About Emotional Harm to the Children
A jointly instructed psychologist, reporting in February 2023, identified risks to the children in their mother’s care arising from their exposure to her negative views of their father. He recommended specialist therapy aimed at improving the parents’ relationship and restoring the children’s relationship with their father.
The guardian assessed that the children had suffered psychological and emotional harm as a result of their mother’s inability effectively to promote their relationship with their father.
The local authority initially described the therapy as crucial, but funding was never provided. The parents later attended introductory sessions with Relate, which said it could not provide the service needed.
In January 2024, the parents agreed a consent order under which the children would live with their mother and spend time with their father, with a shared aim of unsupervised and overnight contact by October 2024. The order recorded that, if progress was not made, the matter could return to court, including the potential for a change in the children’s living arrangements.
The anticipated progress did not materialise, and the father returned to court, as the order had expressly contemplated.
Was the Father Abusing the Court Process?
On 4 February 2025, the Family Court dismissed the father’s applications and made an order under section 91(14) of the Children Act 1989, observing that the family deserved a break from litigation.
The order prevented both parents from making any further section 8 application, or any enforcement application, for three years without first obtaining the court’s permission.
On appeal, the mother argued that she lived with the stress of the father’s continuous litigation, and that his conduct showed an entrenched pattern of coercive and controlling behaviour justifying a lengthy restriction.
Mr Justice Harrison rejected this. He noted that no finding of coercive and controlling conduct had been made, and found that the father had not engaged in “lawfare”.
The judge also concluded that the extraordinary length of the original proceedings was not the father’s fault. He identified the main causes as:
Court listing delays, including 16 months to list the fact-finding hearing.
Errors by the lay justices, which led to their findings being set aside.
The need to appoint, and then change, the children’s guardian.
The mother’s conduct towards the guardian, including objecting to the guardian meeting the children without a third party present and applying to have the guardian removed, which the judge described as an attempt to manipulate the process.
Risks identified in the mother’s care, which required local authority involvement.
Delays and changes of social worker within the local authority.
The case demonstrates why a parent seeking further judicial intervention should not automatically be characterised as engaging in unreasonable or abusive litigation.
High Court Narrows the Three-Year Restriction
The father was refused permission to challenge the making of the section 91(14) order itself. His appeal proceeded only on its duration and scope.
Although the High Court accepted that the children needed protection from the harmful effects of prolonged litigation, it concluded that the original restriction went too far. The judge also cautioned that the desire to ease pressure on court lists should not routinely be used to justify a section 91(14) order where the usual justification is absent.
The appeal succeeded in part:
Living arrangements: the three-year restriction on applications to change where the children live was upheld as proportionate.
Time with the father: the judge considered 12 months proportionate, but extended the restriction to 30 April 2026 because the appeal itself had denied the family the intended break. That restriction has now expired.
All other section 8 applications: the judge saw no need for any restriction, save perhaps for a very short period, and discharged this part of the order immediately.
The decision reinforces an important principle: restrictions on access to the family courts must be tailored to the circumstances, rather than imposed more widely or for longer than necessary.
The Wider Impact of Family Court Failings
The judgment illustrates the consequences of prolonged litigation, unresolved allegations and inconsistent professional involvement.
Both parents represented themselves. The court acknowledged that the absence of legal representation was likely to have aggravated the problems, and that the main casualties had been the children. Because of the Domestic Abuse Act 2021, the parents were also prohibited from cross-examining each other, which made a meaningful fact-finding hearing difficult to achieve.
While the father was not found to have misused the court process, the judge accepted that the prolonged litigation had become harmful to the children.
This distinction is important. A parent’s application may be legitimate, but the court must still consider whether the orders sought are in the children’s best interests.
Falsely Accused Network’s View
At Falsely Accused Network, we believe the family justice system must protect genuine victims of domestic abuse while ensuring that those facing allegations receive a fair and impartial process. These objectives should never be treated as mutually exclusive.
This judgment highlights the difficulties that can arise when serious allegations remain unresolved, professional assessments become inconsistent and proceedings continue for years without meaningful progress.
It also demonstrates the importance of distinguishing between legitimate attempts to resolve child arrangements and the misuse of litigation as a means of control.
The High Court did not establish that the allegations against the father were false. However, it did recognise significant failings in the handling of the case and rejected the claim that his conduct of the litigation amounted to coercive and controlling behaviour.
For families navigating disputed allegations, the consequences of procedural failings can be profound. Children deserve protection. Parents deserve fairness. The family justice system must deliver both.
Need Support With Family Court Proceedings?
Falsely Accused Network provides professional, paid McKenzie Friend support to individuals involved in family court proceedings across England and Wales.
We can assist with Child Arrangements Orders, Non-Molestation Orders, Occupation Orders, hearing preparation and family court documentation.
Our initial call allows us to understand your circumstances, explain the assistance available and provide a quotation before you decide whether to proceed.
Website: www.falselyaccusednetwork.co.uk
Email: support@falselyaccusednetwork.co.uk
Set up by the falsely accused, for the falsely accused.
Case Reference
Re A and T (Children) (Appeal: Duration of section 91(14) order) [2025] EWHC 3052 (Fam). High Court of Justice, Family Division. Mr Justice Harrison. Judgment: 19 November 2025.
Read the full judgment on Find Case Law (The National Archives)
Reporting restrictions: this judgment is subject to an order protecting the anonymity of the children and their family. No identifying information about the family should be published.
Disclaimer: this article is provided for general information and commentary and does not constitute legal advice. McKenzie Friends are not qualified legal representatives merely by virtue of their role and cannot undertake reserved legal activities unless separately authorised.

