FAN logo
Falsely Accused Network
Set up by the falsely accused, for the falsely accused.
Menu

← Back to Blog & Insights

When Domestic Abuse Allegations Are Tested: What B v B Reveals About Evidence, Dishonesty and the Family Court

When Domestic Abuse Allegations Are Tested: What B v B Reveals About Evidence, Dishonesty and the Family Court

Five allegations of physical assault were rejected, a mother admitted deliberately making a false statement about her child witnessing violence, yet the court still found serious domestic abuse. This judgment raises important questions about evidence, credibility, financial control and the consequences of allegations in family proceedings.

Empty family courtroom representing the B v B 2026 fact-finding judgment

Introduction

When allegations of domestic abuse are made during child arrangements proceedings, the consequences can be profound. A parent's relationship with their child may be disrupted, reputations can suffer, and the court may need to determine what happened between two people whose accounts differ considerably.

But what happens when serious allegations cannot be proved? What happens when the person making those allegations admits deliberately making a false statement? And how should the court distinguish ordinary relationship arrangements from coercive or controlling behaviour?

These questions arise in B v B (Economic Abuse and ‘Culture and Tradition’) [2026] EWFC 330 (B), a judgment delivered by Deputy District Judge Baldip Singh at Birmingham Family Court on 2 October 2026.

Following a two-day fact-finding hearing, the court rejected five allegations of physical assault, along with an alleged threat to kill and allegations concerning threats over a family wedding. However, it also found that the father had engaged in serious domestic abuse through repeated verbal humiliation, controlling behaviour, economic abuse and the forcible taking and inspection of the mother's telephone.

Perhaps most significantly, the mother admitted that she had deliberately made a false claim that their young child had witnessed an alleged assault. The judgment offers important lessons about evidence, credibility and the difference between an unproved allegation and a fabricated assertion.

The Background: A Father Seeking Contact With His Son

The parents married in 2019 and had a son in 2023. Their relationship subsequently deteriorated, and the mother left the family home with the child in August 2025. The father last had in-person contact with his son in October 2025 and applied for a Child Arrangements Order in December 2025.

The mother made allegations including physical assaults, threatening behaviour, verbal abuse and coercive control. The court directed a fact-finding hearing before progressing to the final welfare determination.

The police had previously investigated allegations against the father but closed the investigation because of evidential difficulties and an assessment of prosecution prospects. That outcome did not prevent the Family Court considering the allegations.

Unlike criminal proceedings, the Family Court generally determines disputed facts on the balance of probabilities. The burden rests on the person making the allegation. As the judge explained at paragraph 8, the mother had to prove the alleged events; the father was not required to prove they never happened.

Five Physical Assault Allegations Were Not Proved

The mother alleged several incidents of physical violence between 2022 and 2025, including being pushed against a wall and onto a sofa, having her hair pulled, hands placed around her neck, being pushed to the ground and being punched in the stomach.

The court considered each allegation individually and the evidence as a whole. Ultimately, none of those five alleged assaults was proved. Some allegations lacked sufficient detail, while others were affected by inconsistencies or contemporaneous communications.

An allegation being unproved does not automatically establish that it was false. The court may simply be unable to conclude that an event was more likely than not to have happened. That distinction matters to those reporting abuse and those defending allegations.

The Mother's Admission of a Deliberately False Statement

One of the most striking aspects of the judgment concerns an allegation that the father punched the mother in the stomach in July 2025. In November 2025 she sent a message asking whether he had punched her and subsequently asserted that their young son had seen the punch.

During oral evidence, the mother accepted that the child had not witnessed the alleged punch. She admitted that she had deliberately claimed otherwise to make the father feel guilty and obtain an acknowledgement from him.

At paragraph 46, the judge found: “She knowingly presented him as an eyewitness to an act he had not witnessed.” This was a positive finding of dishonesty concerning the child's supposed eyewitness evidence, rather than a mere mistake or imperfect recollection.

The judge did not automatically conclude that the punch itself had been fabricated. A person might falsely strengthen an allegation about something that nevertheless happened. After weighing the evidence, however, he found the punch was not proved.

When a parent deliberately makes a false assertion about a child witnessing violence, what consideration should be given to that conduct in later proceedings concerning the child's welfare? This judgment does not decide that question. Nor does it establish that the underlying allegation was knowingly invented.

At the Falsely Accused Network, we believe deliberate dishonesty should be examined fairly and consistently, regardless of which parent is responsible. That does not mean every inconsistency should be labelled a lie.

Photographs of Injuries: What Do They Actually Prove?

Another allegation concerned an October 2022 incident in which the mother said the father pulled her hair and placed his hands around her neck. Photographs showed visible marks on her cheek.

An earlier police account described scratching and her head being struck against a dining table. Her family court account instead described hair pulling and hands around her neck. The judge recognised that the police statement was unsigned, had been prepared remotely from notes and was said by the mother to contain inaccuracies.

He did not assume the police account was necessarily correct. Nevertheless, the materially different descriptions could not be satisfactorily reconciled. The photographs established the existence and timing of marks, but not that the father caused them in the particular way alleged.

A photograph or medical record may establish an injury without independently establishing how it occurred or who caused it. Such evidence matters, but must be assessed for what it actually proves.

When WhatsApp Messages Tell a Different Story

One allegation concerned a family wedding in October 2023. The mother claimed that the father prevented her taking their son and threatened that she would never see the child again. She also alleged he threatened to make her appear dishonest in court.

Contemporaneous WhatsApp messages showed that the maternal grandfather had advised against attending because of concerns about the child's health. The father's recorded responses were accepting rather than prohibitory.

The judge recognised that the messages could not conclusively exclude a separate private threat, but found they materially undermined the central account. The alleged prohibition and associated threats were not proved.

Preserving complete communications is important. Messages, emails and other records created at the time can support an allegation, undermine it or reveal a more complicated context than either party later describes.

Economic Abuse: When Does Managing Household Finances Become Controlling?

The father earned approximately £70,000 a year, while the mother had not worked since becoming pregnant. He managed the household finances and described that arrangement as consistent with his cultural background.

The judge accepted that families organise their finances differently. One partner earning the income or managing accounts is not, by itself, economic abuse.

The court examined messages in which the mother requested money or permission for modest purchases, including a £3 ebook, £7.74 for nappies and wipes, around £6 for medicine and about £20 for a taxi. The father frequently provided the money promptly.

Nevertheless, the judge concluded that the mother repeatedly depended on his approval or availability to complete ordinary transactions. In one example she requested taxi money but did not receive it immediately because he was in meetings. The judge found that recurring dependence substantially restricted her practical access to money, goods and services and amounted to economic abuse under the Domestic Abuse Act 2021.

This is a difficult distinction. Many households have one principal income and one person managing expenditure. Partners may transfer money or discuss purchases for legitimate budgeting reasons. Those arrangements are not inherently abusive.

The judge distinguished ordinary financial administration from an arrangement where one partner effectively controls the other's access to everyday necessities. He acknowledged that fuller banking records would have assisted, but found the messages and oral evidence sufficient.

That conclusion is reasoned, though it raises a legitimate question about how the statutory requirement of substantial adverse effect is assessed when money is often supplied and financial records are incomplete. It does not follow that the judge was legally wrong.

At paragraph 94, the judge considered choice, control, freedom, justification and practical impact. Those considerations are useful judicial reasoning in this case, not a new binding statutory checklist.

Can Asking Your Partner for Permission Amount to Coercive Control?

The mother produced messages asking whether it was acceptable to meet friends, receive visitors or make social arrangements. The father generally agreed.

Nevertheless, the judge found that she operated under an expectation that she needed his approval before ordinary activities. He relied on the repeated nature of the requests, her oral evidence and messages distinguishing approval from practical matters such as childcare and transport.

Many couples ask whether proposed plans are convenient because of shared responsibilities. The judge expressly acknowledged that such consultation is not inherently controlling.

This judgment does not establish that checking plans with a partner automatically constitutes abuse. The question is whether the surrounding evidence establishes an expectation of control rather than ordinary mutual consideration. Courts must examine context carefully.

Why the Court Still Found Serious Domestic Abuse

Despite rejecting numerous physical assault allegations, the judge found that the father used repeated insulting and humiliating language. He accepted that some exchanges could be mutual banter, but concluded that others amounted to demeaning criticism and emotional abuse.

The court also found that the father forcibly took the mother's telephone and inspected private messages. It rejected additional allegations that he pushed her against a wall, put a hand around her neck or that she held the child at that moment.

Taken together, the judge found a pattern of coercive and controlling behaviour, including psychological, emotional and economic abuse. At paragraph 117 he described the established conduct as very serious domestic abuse.

The father was not cleared of all wrongdoing. Equally, the serious physical assault allegations were not established. Both points must be reported accurately.

What About the Father's Relationship With His Child?

The father had not seen his son in person since October 2025. By the time judgment was delivered in October 2026, approximately a year had passed.

The judgment did not determine final child arrangements. Instead, the judge directed a subsequent section 7 welfare assessment to consider the established abuse, its effects and implications for contact.

Practice Direction 12J requires the Family Court to consider safety and risk where domestic abuse has been established. The judgment does not establish why contact remained absent throughout the period, what alternatives were considered or what happened subsequently.

Nevertheless, the passage of time matters enormously in a young child's life. Effective case management, proportionate fact-finding and timely welfare decisions are essential.

Does an Admitted Lie Mean Everything Else Is False?

The judge did not automatically reject all the mother's evidence because she admitted deliberate dishonesty. A witness may be dishonest about one matter without necessarily being dishonest about everything.

Equally, deliberately introducing false evidence about a material issue can affect credibility. Courts should assess its significance without assuming that every inconsistency is a lie or that every other allegation must be false.

The key is to identify what the evidence actually establishes, allegation by allegation, while considering the evidence as a whole.

What Can We Learn From This Judgment?

The burden of proof rests with the person asserting an allegation. Respondents do not have to prove that alleged events never happened.

Contemporaneous messages, photographs and records can be important, but must be considered in context. Evidence of one form of abusive conduct does not automatically prove every other allegation.

An allegation that is not proved must be distinguished from a deliberate fabrication. Financial dependence or routine discussions about plans are not automatically abusive, although arrangements can become controlling where practical autonomy is restricted.

These distinctions matter because family proceedings concern real people, real relationships and the welfare of children.

Our View: Fairness Requires Proper Scrutiny of Every Allegation

At the Falsely Accused Network, we support people facing false or disputed allegations of domestic abuse in family court proceedings in England and Wales. We recognise that genuine victims deserve protection and that allegations can also be mistaken, exaggerated or deliberately fabricated.

B v B illustrates why evidence and fairness matter. The court rejected five allegations of physical assault and identified deliberate dishonesty by the mother. At the same time, it found serious emotional, controlling and economic abuse by the father.

The case should not be used to argue that the Family Court automatically believes allegations or that every allegation of domestic abuse is false. Instead, it shows the importance of properly testing claims and limiting findings to what has been proved.

The family justice system must be capable of protecting victims while also protecting individuals and children from the consequences of allegations that cannot be substantiated. Those objectives are compatible and essential.

Final Thoughts

The consequences of allegations can extend beyond the fact-finding hearing. Reputations, finances, emotional wellbeing and relationships with children may all be affected.

That is why evidence must be tested, dishonesty properly addressed and findings confined to what has actually been established.

Justice requires more than taking allegations seriously. It requires testing them fairly.

About the Falsely Accused Network

The Falsely Accused Network supports individuals facing false or disputed allegations of domestic abuse in family court proceedings across England and Wales. We provide access to professional McKenzie Friend assistance for child arrangements, non-molestation orders, occupation orders and related family matters. Services are paid and costs are discussed according to the assistance required.

Set up by the falsely accused, for the falsely accused.

Website: www.falselyaccusednetwork.co.uk | Email: support@falselyaccusednetwork.co.uk

Case Reference and Legal Sources

Primary source: B v B (Economic Abuse and ‘Culture and Tradition’) [2026] EWFC 330 (B), Deputy District Judge Baldip Singh, Family Court at Birmingham, 2 October 2026. Relevant paragraphs include 8–16, 30–35, 42–48, 80–106 and 115–120.

Relevant legal context: Domestic Abuse Act 2021; Children Act 1989; Family Procedure Rules 2010, Practice Direction 12J; Re B (Children) [2008] UKHL 35; Re H-N and Others [2021] EWCA Civ 448; K v K [2022] EWCA Civ 468.

Publication note: This article discusses an anonymised judgment. The anonymity of the child and family is preserved. This is commentary on the judgment and does not determine allegations beyond the court's findings.

Disclaimer: This article is general information and commentary about family law in England and Wales, not legal advice.

Request Your Free Initial Call